Peloton was once synonymous with luxury in home fitness, but the tide is turning. With rising prices for new equipment, increased resale activity, and new resale platforms entering the market, 2025 is shaping up to be the year of the used Peloton boom. But is buying secondhand truly worth it? This guide covers what you need to know before investing in a used Peloton bike.
1. Why Now Is a Great Time to Consider a Used Peloton
First, new Peloton models are more expensive. The original Bike now starts around $1,745 and the Tread is $2,845. That price increase motivates buyers to turn to the secondary market.
Second, during the pandemic many bought Pelotons they no longer use. Now gyms and studios are back in full swing, creating a surplus of well-maintained bikes on resale sites.
Finally, Peloton’s official resale marketplace Repowered has launched, offering curated, vetted listings and added confidence for buyers.
2. Price Overview: Used versus Refurbished versus New versus Rental
New Peloton bikes retail as follows:
• Bike: $1,745
• Bike Plus: $2,495
These options include warranty coverage and delivery.
Refurbished bikes, sold directly by Peloton, offer savings:
• Bike: about $1,145
• Bike Plus: around $1,995
These include a one-year warranty and full inspection.
Used bikes sold peer-to-peer typically go for:
• Bike: between $800 and $1,200
• Bike Plus: $1,200 to $1,500
They must be activated via Peloton with a one-time fee.
Rentals can cost $119 per month plus a $150 delivery fee, mostly for the Bike Plus. Over time, the total cost exceeds the price of purchasing new.
Value comparison
Used bikes present significant savings, especially when they cost close to $1,000. Refurbished bikes add warranty protection but cost more. Rentals can be useful for short-term experimentation but aren’t cost-effective in the long run.
3. What You Are Actually Paying For
A used Peloton purchase adds more costs than just the sticker price:
A one-time activation fee
• The monthly All-Access membership fee of $44
• Repair and maintenance costs, since warranties are typically not transferable
Example: A $1,200 used Bike, plus a $95 activation fee and $44 monthly, comes out to around $1,500 in total still much cheaper than buying new.
4. Risks and Red Flags
No warranty
Unless the previous owner still has an active transferable warranty, used bikes will not be covered in case of defects.
Potential hidden damage
Items like pedals, bearings, and seat posts may need replacement. Look out for sweat damage, missing recall fixes, or worn parts.
Rental bikes are off-limits
Peloton does not activate subscriptions on rental bikes purchased in peer-to-peer transactions.
Model generation matters
Avoid Gen 1 bikes, which no longer receive software updates. Choose Gen 2 or Gen 3 for future support.
5. Platforms to Use and Avoid
Facebook Marketplace and local Peloton resale groups are popular, with many listings and in-person inspection options.
Craigslist, OfferUp, and eBay are useful but vary in seller reliability and shipping logistics.
Repowered and services like Trade My Stuff provide quality control, inspected bikes, delivery, and short-term warranty options.
Choosing official resale offers peace of mind. For larger savings, peer-to-peer with careful inspection can work.
6. Pre-Purchase Inspection Checklist
Take this checklist when you view a potential bike:
Verify serial number to check generation and recall status.
Ask for the original purchase receipt to confirm it is not a rental bike.
Inquire about usage patterns, maintenance history, and any repairs.
Physically inspect for frame cracks, seat-post safety, rust, or brittle parts.
Do a test ride to hear for noise, test resistance, and confirm screen function.
Clarify what’s included shoes, weights, subscription credits.
7. Smart Buying Tactics
Negotiate using evidence about maintenance costs or missing warranty. Factor in delivery logistics to save money. Avoid Gen 1 units. Prioritize bikes with documented recall fixes.
8. Is Renting Ever a Good Option?
Renting a Bike Plus at $119 per month is only worthwhile for short-term use, testing commitment, or temporary moves. After about two years, total rental costs exceed the price of purchase.
9. Final Take
Pros of buying used:
• Major savings compared to new
• Fully functional and community-tested
• More supply and quality channels available
Cons:
• No warranty adds risk for repairs
• Requires careful vetting
• Subscription cost remains
Used bikes are great if you ride several times per week, are OK handling minor repairs, and can do an in-person inspection.
10. Next Steps
Set a budget including fees and membership.
Browse official resale, then peer-to-peer platforms.
Print out the inspection checklist and take it with you.
Ask detailed questions during inspection and test rides.
Do cost calculations including all fees.
Negotiate smartly knowing the fair price is around $800 to $1,200.
11. After You Buy
• Activate the bike with Peloton using the $95 fee.
• Transfer any remaining membership credits.
• Ensure you can sign in and stream workouts.
• Maintain by cleaning, replacing bearings and pedals.
• Keep resale value in mind if you might sell in the future.
Summary
At Reperch, we believe that buying secondhand is about making smarter, more intentional choices and a used Peloton fits right into that philosophy. In 2025, the resale market is full of well-maintained bikes that offer premium performance without the premium price tag. Whether you’re starting your fitness journey or upgrading your home gym, buying used allows you to save money, reduce waste, and still enjoy everything Peloton has to offer.
Just be sure to inspect carefully, ask the right questions, and factor in any additional fees. With a bit of research and the right platform, you can find a high-quality Peloton bike that delivers top-notch workouts and long-term value. It’s a smart move for your health, your wallet, and the planet.
